By: Elizabeth Leclaire, Dezan Shira&Associates
China’s rapid urbanization, swelling aging population and heightened pollution crisis have triggered a need for improved health care, particularly within China’s largest cities. Within the next three years alone, Chinese healthcare expenditure is predicted to increase at 11.8 percent annually. In order to accommodate for the growing demand for proper health care services, China’s National Health and Family Planning Commission (NHFPC) permitted Wholly Foreign Owned Hospitals (WFOH) in seven Chinese cities and provinces on July 25th, 2014. Under these new regulations, Beijing, Tianjin, Shanghai, Jiangsu, Fujian, Guangdong and Hainan may be home to foreign owned hospitals, but their establishment in any other location within China remains strictly forbidden.
Nevertheless, the expansion of WFOH’s freedom within these seven cities and provinces presents great opportunities for FDIs, so long as investors are conscious of the requirements, limitations, and challenges that come with opening a foreign-owned hospital in China.
In addition to the NHFPC’s WFOH location requirements, foreign-owned hospitals must meet several additional criteria:
- WFOH must be capable of independently bearing civil liabilities.
- WFOH must have experience in medical fields, health investment, and management.
- WFOH also must meet national medical institute standards.
- WFOH must be capable of meeting at least one of the following requirements:
- Offering advanced hospital management ideas and service models.
- Offering advanced medical technology and equipment.
- Improving local medical service, technology, funds, or facilities.
- WFOH cannot engage in the practice of Traditional Chinese Medicine (unless foreign investor is from Hong Kong, Taiwan, or Macau).
Application to Establish a WFOH
Foreign investors considering capitalizing upon new WFOH rights in China should bear in mind that the application process to establish a WFOH can often be lengthy in itself. WFOH’s must first file an application for pre-approval to the relevant Municipal Health and Family Planning administration, as well as any local departments of traditional Chinese medicine. If approved, the application will be transferred to the provincial Health and Family Planning administration for a second approval. A final review will be conducted by provincial business departments to determine if the WFOH meets the criteria to establish a hospital within China.
Hospitals in China are divided into three distinct categories: primary, secondary, and tertiary, and foreign investors may establish the hospital that best suits their business needs. Chinese primary hospitals are relatively small, mainly serving local constituents and only capable of housing a maximum of 100 patients.
Secondary hospitals hold between 100 and 500 patients, and typically engage in small scale medical research and medical education in addition to providing health services.
The largest and most comprehensive Chinese hospitals fall under the tertiary category. To qualify as a tertiary, hospitals must be capable of housing a minimum of 500 patients, must offer medical services to larger regions within China, and are required to conduct extensive medical research.
Additionally, WFOHs may choose to establish foreign owned hospitals either as greenfield or brownfield projects. The 2012 Revision of China’s Foreign Investment Catalogue officially allows for the privatization of public hospitals for the first time. This means that WFOHs may independently construct and establish foreign hospitals, convert private Chinese hospitals to foreign hospitals, or even convert public Chinese hospitals into private WFOHs.
As of April 2014, the National Development and Reform Commission, the National Health and Family Planning Commission and the Ministry of Human Resources and Social Security passed a joint policy declaring that private hospital care is required to be included on public medical insurance plans. This shift greatly expanded private hospital’s consumer base, which was previously confined to serving wealthier Chinese who could absorb the private medical costs without relying on insurance.
A WFOH in China must again overcome several hurdles even after given clearance to establish the hospital, particularly in the aspect of employment. WFOHs looking to hire foreign doctors should be aware that foreign doctors will only receive permits to practice medicine in China for one year. According to China’s Administration of Foreign Doctors, the WFOH and doctor must both annually resubmit an application in order for the doctor to retain employment in China.
Hiring local doctors can be met with even more complications. WFOHs may encounter difficulty locating Chinese doctors who are willing to change from working at public Chinese hospital to a WFOH. Public hospitals offer guaranteed employment through retirement and are viewed a prestigious occupation. Additionally, employment at more than one hospital is nearly impossible in China, as it requires permission from the original public hospital and relevant health administration department.
Lastly, the very establishment of a WFOH has proven difficult in China. Currently, foreign hospitals from a range of countries including the United States and Germany are in the early stages of entrance into China’s hospital sector. Even a year after its publication, the law remains ambiguous as to specific standards and measures in establishing a foreign hospital. The bureaucratic nature of the WFOH registration process has also stalled the industry’s progress. Although the NHFPC’s allowance of WFOHs indicates China’s willingness for foreign hospital ownership, investors should take caution when entering this relatively new and oftentimes sluggish market.
This article was first published on China Briefing.
Since its establishment in 1992, Dezan Shira & Associates has been guiding foreign clients through Asia’s complex regulatory environment and assisting them with all aspects of legal, accounting, tax, internal control, HR, payroll and audit matters. As a full-service consultancy with operational offices across China, Hong Kong, India and emerging ASEAN, we are your reliable partner for business expansion in this region and beyond.